Prohibition Pizza wins Pizza Excellence Award in High Springs

Prohibition Pizza in High Springs, Florida, earned the Pizza Excellence Award from the Consumer Ratings Institute after drawing a 4.7-star rating across 602 reviews. The recognition adds to a string of recent honors for the artisan pizzeria and reinforces its standing in the local dining market.

Why it matters: - The award signals strong customer trust for a local restaurant competing in a crowded pizza market. - Prohibition Pizza’s 4.7-star rating across 602 reviews helped support the recognition. - The honor adds outside validation to a business built around handcrafted pizza and community appeal.

What happened: - Prohibition Pizza won the Pizza Excellence Award for High Springs from the Consumer Ratings Institute. - The award recognizes the restaurant’s handcrafted approach to pizza and its role in the local dining community. - The pizzeria is owned by husband-and-wife team Kelly and David Potter. - The restaurant is in High Springs, Florida, across from High Springs Brewing Company.

The details: - Prohibition Pizza is an artisan New York-style pizzeria. - The menu centers on New York-style pizzas made with handmade dough fermented for 72 hours. - The restaurant uses daily-sliced, fresh, natural toppings. - The menu also includes oven-baked wings, salads and desserts. - Gluten-free options are available for guests with dietary restrictions. - Prohibition Pizza serves a curated wine list and rotating craft beers from neighboring High Springs Brewing Company. - The Potters describe the restaurant as a family-driven dream. - Prohibition Pizza was voted Best Pizza in Florida in 2024, 2025 and 2026. - The restaurant was named Best Lunch by the Gainesville Sun in 2024. - Prohibition Pizza took second place for Best Cheese Pizza at the 2024 Galbani Cup. - The Consumer Ratings Institute is an independent organization that evaluates businesses based on verified consumer feedback and consistent service quality.

Between the lines: - The award suggests customers view Prohibition Pizza as more than a neighborhood spot; the restaurant has built a broader reputation for consistency. - Multiple awards over several years point to repeat recognition, not a one-time bump. - The emphasis on handmade dough, fresh ingredients and service quality fits the criteria behind the Consumer Ratings Institute honor.

What's next: - Prohibition Pizza will continue serving High Springs and the surrounding area from its current location. - The restaurant is expected to keep leaning on locally inspired ingredients and friendly, knowledgeable service. - More information or the menu is available at the company’s website.